Oberon Matters
Local news for local people

Book review: "Lunacy: Ten false promises of the New Space Age" by Ben Bramble

November 19, 2026

Adelaide was settled in 1836 and was unique at the time for not being established with any convict population - everyone there was a volunteer. 190 years later the city has a population just under 1.5 million.

Now I want you to imagine that Adelaide hadn't been created next to an ocean and a river and with no arable land nearby, with no breathable atmosphere, much more than a few days travel from the nearest reasonably sized city and with communications with other places taking days. Say, under a big airtight dome in the middle of the Sahara Desert. How long would it have taken to get to the current population with all the infrastructure and resources necessary to support the population? That's what building a city of Adelaide's size on Mars would be like.

People have been fascinated with Mars for a very long time and going there to live has long been a dream. I really liked Ray Bradbury's novel "The Martian Chronicles" but Bradbury new full well that it was fiction. It wasn't going to happen.

Into this we have people like Elon Musk confidently predicting settlements of a million people on Mars within the lifetimes of people born since Bradbury wrote his book in 1950. That's the sort of thing this book is about, and the title "Lunacy" sums it up well.

Another fantasy of the "let's move to space" crowd is "terraforming", where massive earthworks are done to create a resemblance to Earth geography. If you want to see some massive earthworks, consider the Ulan coal mine in NSW. If you have ever been near there you will know just how big it is and how much dirt had to be removed to make it. The picture below was taken at an altitude of 105 kilometres. You can't see the mine from the Moon. Now think about how much effort it would take to build the full Great Dividing Range from scratch.

To get a feel for the book, here is the list of the reasons people say we have to go out into space (from the Table of Contents):

  1. To Back Up Humanity
  2. To Save Earth
  3. To Achieve Abundance
  4. To Grow Humanity
  5. To Give Humanity an Amazing Future
  6. To End War
  7. To Meet Aliens
  8. To Do Science
  9. To Excite and Inspire
  10. To Go on Holiday

Bramble addresses each of these "reasons" comprehensively, explaining why each is either unnecessary, impossible, too hard, too expensive or can be done without leaving Earth. As the subtitle of the book says, they are all false promises. There are much better ways to spend our time and money.

It's rare to read a book where as I turn each page I say "Yes. That's correct", but this is one. I remember being awestruck as I watched the images of Armstrong stepping onto the moon, but we've been there, done that and don't really need to do it again.

This book comes highly commended and you can get a copy from the Bathurst Library.


About the Author




Copyright © 2024 -  Oberon Matters
An Oberon Media project
ABN 41 518 658 205
Find us on Facebook